A new Epstein forensic report has reopened one of the most argued-over deaths in modern American history. Forensic scientist Professor Michael Freeman told BBC Newsnight on Monday, 16 November 2026, that after reviewing Jeffrey Epstein's full autopsy file he believes the disgraced financier was strangled in his New York prison cell in August 2019, and that the official ruling of suicide by hanging does not fit the injuries. The New York City medical examiner's office, which ruled the death a suicide in 2019, said on Monday that it stands by its determination. The report, presented in London and covered by the BBC, CBS News, CNN and The New York Times, is trending per news coverage, but it changes nothing officially: no authority has altered the 2019 ruling.
What the Epstein forensic report actually says
Freeman, a scholar and consultant in forensic medicine and epidemiology and the editor-in-chief of the Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, spent months reviewing autopsy records and photographs that had not previously been published. The files were provided by Epstein's brother, Mark Epstein, who has always maintained that his brother was murdered. Freeman presented the findings on Monday evening at the Middle Temple in London, working with forensic pathologist Anders Eriksson of Umea University in Sweden and cognitive neuroscientist Itiel Dror, and he published his research together with the New York City medical examiner's files, including portions that had not previously been public. The Epstein forensic report is the most detailed public challenge to the official account since 2020.
His conclusion, in his own words to the BBC, was blunt: "The injuries and the way the body was found don't match up. There's only one remaining explanation then, and that is that the death was as a result of a homicide." The Epstein forensic report concludes that the evidence was "most consistent with a homicidal strangulation from behind using a narrow knotted fabric ligature" — most likely, he said, a double-knotted strip of orange fabric used for bedding at the jail — and that the same ligature was probably then used to suspend the body from the bunk bed, making the scene look like a hanging.
Freeman stressed that he did not examine Epstein's body directly, that his review was independent, and that Mark Epstein did not pay him. He also said he had no opinion about who might have been involved, telling the BBC he had "no idea" who could have killed Epstein if his reading is right.
The injuries Freeman says point to strangulation
The Epstein forensic report rests its case on a list of injuries he says do not fit a suicidal hanging. He pointed to what appeared to be fingernail marks above the ligature line on Epstein's neck, which he told the BBC "would be consistent with strangulation, particularly from behind." He cited a second ligature mark below the first, angled differently, and a deep haemorrhage in the left shoulder muscle that he said was consistent with blunt force trauma. He also described injuries to the face — cuts and darkened tissue on the lips — that he said were consistent with being struck, an abrasion at the base of the neck, and a neck injury that was deep, ragged and branched into a Y-shape on one side.
To test his reading, Freeman built a three-dimensional biomechanical reconstruction from the photographs and from the account of corrections officer Michael Thomas, who said he found Epstein hanging from a bedpost in a near-seated posture. The model, he told CBS News, showed that some of the neck wounds were consistent with hanging, but others — including the shoulder injury — were not. Freeman also criticised gaps in the original investigation: no photograph was taken of the body while it was still suspended, no DNA samples were taken from beneath Epstein's fingernails, and the strip of orange fabric found in a corner of the cell was not collected for the medical examiner.
Freeman suggested the hanging could have been "staged". As he put it to the BBC: "If we believe the guard's sworn statement, then the only explanation for the hanging is that it was staged, likely using the same ligature." If the guard's account is not believed, he added, there is no reason to consider hanging as part of the finding at all.
Why the medical examiner stands by suicide
The Epstein forensic report drew a swift response from the medical examiner's office. The New York City Office of Chief Medical Examiner said in a statement to CNN that it "stands by its determination" that Epstein died by suicide and that the manner was hanging. Dr Barbara Sampson, the city's chief medical examiner at the time, ruled the death a suicide by hanging in 2019. Dr Kristin Roman, who performed the autopsy, told the Justice Department's Office of the Inspector General that Epstein's injuries were far more indicative of suicide by hanging than strangulation, and said there was no evidence of the defensive wounds seen in strangulation victims. In a statement quoted by The New York Times, Roman said: "This doesn't look anything like a strangulation."
The office's position has been backed by federal reviews. A 2023 report by Justice Department Inspector General Michael Horowitz found that jail staff falsified records to show checks that were never performed and that nearly all cameras around Epstein's unit failed to record — but the FBI determined there was no criminality in the death itself. A Justice Department and FBI memorandum issued on 7 July 2025 again concluded that Epstein died by suicide, and said no client list or blackmail operation had been identified in the files. And in June 2026, The New York Times reported that newly released documents and Epstein's handwritten jail notes indicated he intended to end his life.
The Epstein forensic report has not been peer-reviewed. He told CBS News that his report was rejected for publication by an academic journal and that he plans to resubmit it. That matters, because peer review is where forensic claims are tested by independent specialists before they are treated as settled science — and it has not happened here. Until it does, his conclusion remains one expert's reading of the same file the medical examiner used to reach the opposite conclusion.
What happened in Epstein's cell in August 2019
Epstein, 66, was found unresponsive in his locked cell at the Metropolitan Correctional Center in Manhattan at about 6:30 a.m. on 10 August 2019, while awaiting trial on sex trafficking charges. The city medical examiner's office conducted the autopsy the next day and ruled the cause of death hanging and the manner suicide. Doubt about that ruling began almost immediately: in 2020, forensic pathologist Dr Michael Baden, hired by Mark Epstein, told CBS News' "60 Minutes" that he too believed the evidence pointed to homicide, making Freeman the second outside expert to dispute the official finding.
The Epstein forensic report is the latest chapter in a case that has stayed in the public eye ever since, fuelled by the failures documented around the death: guards who did not make their rounds, cameras that did not record, and a cell that the medical examiner was not permitted to inspect. It is the kind of high-profile federal case the US justice system is judged on, as in the Supreme Court's rejection of the 9/11 plea deal for Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, and the FBI's role in the aftermath has been scrutinised ever since, as in the FBI seizure of $1.2 billion in crypto stolen from Binance — but none of that changes what the autopsy file itself shows, and the two sides read it differently.
What the Epstein forensic report does not prove
Three limits matter. First, the findings are unreviewed: a journal has already rejected the paper, and no independent peer review has validated Freeman's reconstruction. Second, Freeman worked only from photographs and files, never from the body itself, and those files came from Mark Epstein, a man who has always believed his brother was murdered; Freeman says his analysis was independent and unpaid, but the provenance is part of the story. Third, the Epstein forensic report names no suspect and offers no account of who would have entered the cell: Freeman himself says he has no idea who might have been involved, and he told the BBC he does not care who it was.
None of that makes the report unimportant. It is the most detailed challenge yet to the official account, built from the complete autopsy file rather than from speculation, and it comes from a forensic scientist with a serious record — Freeman served as a cause-of-death expert for US attorneys-general in death-in-custody cases, including George Floyd's, and testified against Minneapolis officer Derek Chauvin at his murder trial. But a challenge is not a verdict, and the official ruling has not moved.
What happens next
Freeman plans to resubmit the Epstein forensic report for peer review, and whether a journal accepts it will be the first real test of his reconstruction. The medical examiner's office has given no sign of reopening the case, and no official body has changed the 2019 ruling. For now the public record holds two incompatible readings of the same autopsy file: one that sees a staged hanging, and one that sees a suicide. What the Epstein forensic report has done is force both readings back into the open — with the photographs, the files and the reconstruction now published for anyone to examine.
Sources: BBC Newsnight; CBS News; CNN; The New York Times; New York City Office of Chief Medical Examiner; US Department of Justice Office of the Inspector General.