The California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected by voters on Monday 9 November 2026 closed one of the most expensive ballot fights in the state's history. With about 83% of ballots counted, 52.8% of voters had said no to a one-time 5% tax on residents worth more than $1 billion, against 47.2% in favour, and the Associated Press called the result for the no side that evening, with NBC News also projecting failure. The measure would have raised an estimated $100 billion over five years, mostly for health care, and its defeat leaves a gap in California's plans to cover federal cuts to Medi-Cal, the state's Medicaid programme. Supporters have already said they will try again in 2028, so the vote settles one campaign but not the argument behind it.
How the California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected vote unfolded
Californians voted on Proposition 40 on Tuesday 3 November, but the result took almost a week to call because most ballots arrive by mail and counting continued for days. The Associated Press called the race for the no side on the evening of Monday 9 November, when about 83.3% of the expected vote had been counted, according to the California Secretary of State figures reported by the Palm Springs Desert Sun. At that point the tally stood at roughly 5.91 million no votes to 5.29 million yes votes, a margin of about 621,000, according to Secretary of State figures cited by the San Francisco Standard. The gap had narrowed from election night, when the no side led by more, but the yes vote never closed it. The California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected result was not uniform across the state. San Francisco backed the measure by about 56% to 44%, the Standard reported, and the Los Angeles Times reported major pockets of support in Los Angeles. Silicon Valley went the other way: in Santa Clara County the measure was failing 53.4% to 46.6%, and in San Mateo County it was failing 54.1% to 45.9%, according to county returns compiled by The Ballot Book. That split mattered, because the tax would have fallen on the tech founders and investors concentrated in those counties. The result was projected by two major outlets on the same day, which is why the call carried weight even though counting continued and the result remains unofficial until the Secretary of State certifies it on 11 December. The California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected outcome stood out against the wider election: Democrats won big nationally on 3 November, yet in California their own governor opposed this measure, and voters sided with him.
What Proposition 40 would have done
Proposition 40, the California Billionaire Tax Act, would have imposed a one-time 5% tax on the net worth of state residents worth more than $1 billion, applying to people who lived in California on 1 January 2026. The tax would have been due in 2027, with an option to spread payment over five years at additional cost, according to reporting on the measure's terms. About 200 people would have been affected, and the California Budget and Policy Center estimates they hold a combined $2 trillion in wealth. Backers, led by the health care union SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West, estimated the tax would raise about $100 billion over five years. Most of the money was earmarked for health care, above all Medi-Cal, which provides health coverage to low-income Californians. The measure was designed by the French-American economists Gabriel Zucman and Emmanuel Saez, Le Monde reported, and its supporters presented it as a first-in-the-nation wealth tax that could start a wider debate about taxing billionaires. The Legislative Analyst's Office said in its analysis that the state would likely collect tens of billions of dollars from the tax, a more cautious figure than the backers' $100 billion estimate. Other estimates varied more sharply: the National Taxpayers Union Foundation estimated California could collect $40 billion, but could lose $25 billion in other taxes if wealthy people left the state. Real property holdings were excluded from the net-worth calculation, and the tax would have applied to a California-domiciled billionaire's holdings across the globe, a feature critics said invited constitutional challenges. The design of the California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected by voters was simple on its face, a flat 5% on fortunes above $1 billion, but the revenue forecasts depended heavily on who stayed, what assets were counted, and how the courts would treat a retroactive levy.
Why California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected matters for Medi-Cal
The health care funding behind the California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected by voters is where its defeat bites hardest. Supporters said Proposition 40 was a response to federal health care spending cuts in the Republicans' One Big Beautiful Bill Act, which CNN reported would leave California facing a shortfall of about $20 billion a year, threatening the Medi-Cal programme. Medi-Cal covers millions of low-income Californians, and the state had been counting on the billionaire tax to offset part of that loss. Without it, the state must find other money, cut services, or wait for Washington to change course. The debate over the tax was therefore also a debate about who pays for health care when federal support shrinks. Backers argued that a one-time levy on about 200 people was a fair way to protect a programme used by millions. Opponents, including Governor Gavin Newsom, argued that the tax would drive wealthy residents and their spending out of the state, shrinking the tax base over time. Newsom instead proposed a national tax on billionaires, a position CNN linked to his possible 2028 presidential ambitions. Governor-elect Xavier Becerra also opposed the measure, and at a CNN debate in late September he said he would vote no. The split inside the Democratic Party was one of the campaign's defining features: the state Democratic Party supported Proposition 40, while its two most prominent leaders opposed it, and progressive supporters including Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont and Representative Ro Khanna of California campaigned for a yes vote. Voters ultimately sided with the opponents, which means the Medi-Cal funding question now returns to the legislature and the governor's office without the $100 billion the backers had promised.
The 378 million dollar campaign behind the result
Money shaped this race more than almost any other ballot fight in California's history. Supporters of Proposition 40 raised $33.5 million, according to campaign finance data reported by the Desert Sun. Opponents spent about $378 million, more than ten times as much, according to CalMatters' tally reported on 9 November. Google co-founder Sergey Brin alone contributed about $102 million, the Associated Press reported, funnelling the money into Building a Better California, a political action committee that raised more than $333 million in total to defeat the measure, according to Wealth Professional. Other tech figures also spent heavily: Palantir and PayPal co-founder Peter Thiel and Google co-founder Larry Page were reported to have moved some assets to Florida, and Meta chief executive Mark Zuckerberg, who had pledged to remain in California, would have faced a potential tax bill of about $12.5 billion if the measure had passed, Realtor.com reported. The spending gap in the California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected campaign did not decide the vote on its own, since voters also heard the arguments about fairness, flight risk and health care funding, but it meant the no campaign could dominate television, mail and online advertising for months. The companion measures on the same ballot tell the rest of the story. Proposition 42, a constitutional ban on new state taxes on personal property and certain retroactive taxes, was leading 51.6% to 48.4% on the morning of Tuesday 10 November but had not been called by the Associated Press. If it passes, it would make a future wealth tax much harder to enact. Proposition 41, which would prohibit new state taxes that exclude revenue from the state spending limit, was projected to fail, according to the Associated Press. The pattern across the three measures shows why the California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected result happened, with voters rejecting the billionaire tax while still weighing the countermeasures designed to block it. The scale of the spending also puts the race in a wider context: US inflation remained a live concern for voters in the same election season, and global trade tensions were reshaping the economy that California's tech wealth depends on.
What happens after California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected
The campaign behind the California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected vote is not conceding the argument. Suzanne Jimenez, Proposition 40's sponsor and chief of staff at SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West, said the campaign plans to pursue a billionaire tax on the ballot in 2028, the Desert Sun reported, and CalMatters reported that union leaders vowed to try again in 2028 if the legislature fails to deliver a real solution for health care funding. That promise sets up a second campaign after the California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected result, but the conditions for it are worse than in 2026: if Proposition 42 passes, it would bar retroactive taxes and new taxes on personal property, narrowing the legal path for a repeat measure. The Secretary of State certifies the final result on 11 December, and until then the percentages may shift slightly as the remaining ballots are counted, though the Associated Press has already determined the no side cannot be overtaken. In Congress, meanwhile, Representative Ro Khanna and Senator Bernie Sanders introduced a federal version earlier this year, the Make Billionaires Pay Their Fair Share Act, which would impose a federal 5% tax on American billionaires. That effort now becomes the main national vehicle for the idea, and its fate will depend on a Congress that has just changed hands. For California, the immediate question after the California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected result is the state budget: the Medi-Cal shortfall of about $20 billion a year identified by CNN does not go away because the tax failed, and the governor and legislature must decide how to fill it. The California Proposition 40 billionaire tax rejected vote also leaves a political lesson that both parties will study. A tax on 200 people, backed by a union and opposed by the state's own Democratic governor, lost by 5.6 points in a state where Democrats otherwise won. Whether that reflects doubts about the tax itself, fear of wealthy residents leaving, or the sheer weight of $378 million in opposition spending is the question the 2028 campaign will have to answer. Elsewhere, governments are also wrestling with how to tax wealth without driving it away, as Argentina's peso slide showed the same week.