The BR Shetty NMC fraud ruling handed down on 5 November 2026 closes one chapter of the largest corporate collapse the Gulf has seen, and opens another. In a judgment of more than 200 pages, the Abu Dhabi Global Market (ADGM) Court of First Instance found NMC Health founder Dr Bavaguthu Raghuram Shetty and former chief executive Prasanth Manghat liable for fraudulent and wrongful trading under the ADGM Insolvency Regulations 2022. Justice Sir Andrew Smith found that both men had dishonestly and knowingly participated in a fraud that ran for years, and said of Shetty: "In my judgment, Dr Shetty was dishonest." The case is a civil one, brought by the administrators of NMC, and it is not a criminal conviction. At the centre of the case sits a starting figure of $5.397 billion, a number that needs careful reading, because it is not the sum either man has been ordered to pay.

What the BR Shetty NMC fraud ruling decided

The administrators of NMC brought the case after the healthcare group collapsed into administration in April 2020 with debts far larger than its published accounts had shown. They argued that Shetty and Manghat had run the company through years of dishonest borrowing and concealed liabilities. After a long trial, the court accepted the core of that case. It found both men liable for fraudulent trading and wrongful trading, the two insolvency offences that allow a court to order directors and others involved in a company's management to contribute to its assets.

The judgment puts the relevant period at 30 April 2012 to 9 April 2020, and records that the existence of a massive and sophisticated fraud from 2 April 2012 to 9 April 2020 was not disputed. Both men denied the findings against them, and the court rejected their defences. Shetty, who is 84, was reported to be surprised and disappointed by the outcome and to be considering an appeal. Manghat was found liable alongside him, and the court also upheld a separate claim by ADCB against Manghat, for about $1.02 billion outstanding plus $169 million in lost profit.

One point matters more than any other for readers following this story. This was a civil and insolvency judgment, not a criminal trial. The court was deciding whether the two men should pay money into NMC's estate, not whether they should go to prison. No criminal conviction follows from this ruling, and the distinction shapes everything that happens next, because the sums involved will be decided by further argument about contributions, not by a sentence. Anyone trying to follow how court cases work will find the same split in most countries: a civil finding of fraud and a criminal prosecution are different proceedings with different consequences.

How NMC grew, and how the fraud worked

Shetty founded NMC in Abu Dhabi in 1975, building a single clinic into one of the largest private healthcare groups in the Gulf. By the time it listed in London it had become a FTSE 100 company, running hospitals and clinics across the United Arab Emirates and beyond, and borrowing heavily to fund its growth. For years, its published accounts showed a healthy, expanding business. The court found that the reality was very different.

By the end of 2018, the court found, NMC carried about $3.89 billion in undisclosed borrowings, set against about $1.99 billion of reported debt. In other words, the group's true borrowings were roughly three times the figure its accounts showed. Lenders who thought they were dealing with a solid FTSE 100 borrower were, on the court's findings, dealing with a company whose debts had been kept off the books. The judgment also traced large sums moving into Shetty's personal accounts: about AED 4.18 billion gross, and about AED 2.6 billion net once counter-payments were taken into account.

The collapse, when it came, was fast. Questions about NMC's accounts surfaced in late 2019, the shares were suspended, and in April 2020 the group was placed in administration. Hospitals kept treating patients while administrators took control of a business whose finances had to be rebuilt almost from scratch. The scale of the gap between reported and real debt is what turned a corporate failure into a case about fraud, and it is also what made the case so long: the court had to trace years of borrowing, transfers and accounting across several countries. It was not the only large fraud case to reach the courts in this period. A separate healthcare fraud case in Minnesota involving $41 million, and another large fraud case in the UK courts over seized Bitcoin, show how often healthcare and financial fraud now cross borders.

The BR Shetty NMC fraud ruling and the $5.397bn figure: what it is, and what it is not

The number most headlines carried was $5.397 billion. The BR Shetty NMC fraud ruling uses that figure as the starting point for the contributions Shetty and Manghat may be ordered to make to NMC's assets. A starting point is not a final award. The court has not yet fixed how much each man must pay, and the exact amounts will be decided after further submissions from the parties. That follow-up stage is where the real financial consequences will be set, and it is the hearing creditors will watch most closely.

Some money has already been recovered through separate settlements. Bank of Baroda settled a $600 million claim confidentially in July this year, without any admission of liability. EY, NMC's former auditor, settled a £2 billion claim confidentially in February this year in the London High Court. Those settlements sit outside the ADGM judgment, and the confidential terms mean the public does not know how much was actually paid. They still matter, because they show that the administrators have been recovering money on several fronts at once, and that the ADGM case is one part of a wider recovery effort rather than the whole of it.

Readers should treat the $5.397 billion with the same care the court did. It is the scale of the loss the court started from, not a cheque that has been written. If the follow-up hearing reduces the contributions, or if an appeal succeeds, the final sums could be very different. Equally, the figure shows why creditors have pursued this case for years: the gap between what NMC reported and what it owed ran into the billions, and only a judgment of this size can begin to close it.

What happens next

The next stage is a hearing on contributions, where the parties will argue over how much each man should pay and over what period. The court will weigh the losses caused by the fraud, the sums already recovered, and the personal circumstances of each man. Shetty's reported intention to consider an appeal adds another layer: an appeal would challenge the findings themselves, while the contributions hearing works out their financial consequences. Both tracks can run in sequence, and either could take months.

For creditors, the ruling changes the shape of the recovery but not its speed. A finding of liability is a strong foundation, and it lets the administrators pursue the two men for contributions with the court's backing. Turning that into cash is a slower job, involving assets in several countries and the usual limits on what can be recovered from individuals. The ADCB claim against Manghat, at about $1.02 billion plus $169 million in lost profit, is part of the same picture: a series of judgments and settlements that together decide how much of the money lost in the collapse ever comes back.

Why the BR Shetty NMC fraud ruling matters beyond NMC

The BR Shetty NMC fraud ruling matters beyond one company because NMC was not a small business that failed quietly. It was a FTSE 100 healthcare group, audited, listed and borrowed from by some of the largest banks in the region. Its collapse raised hard questions about how a listed company could hide billions in debt for years, what its auditors missed, and how closely lenders checked the numbers they were given. The court's findings answer some of those questions in detail, and the 200-page judgment will be studied by lawyers, auditors and regulators across the Gulf and in London.

For patients and staff, the ruling is history rather than news: NMC's hospitals were restructured years ago, and the group that exists today is a different business from the one Shetty built. For creditors, lenders and anyone who followed the collapse, the ruling is the first full judicial account of what happened, and the starting point for the money that may still be recovered. The follow-up hearing on contributions, and any appeal, will decide how much of that $5.397 billion starting point becomes real money. Until then, the judgment stands as the court's answer to a fraud that ran for eight years and left one of the Gulf's best-known companies in ruins.