Here is the number that explains most of what you need to know about index funds. Over the 15 years covered by S&P's SPIVA scorecard, using data last published in mid-2024, 88% of actively managed funds failed to beat the S&P 500. An index fund is the fund that does not even try. What is an index fund, in plain terms? It is a fund that buys the same stocks, in the same proportions, as a market index — the S&P 500 is the best-known example — and then mostly leaves them alone. There is no star manager picking winners, no constant trading, and the fees are often measured in hundredths of a percent. This guide explains how they work, what they cost, how they differ from ETFs and ordinary mutual funds, and how to buy your first one — and the risks, because they can fall as well as rise.

What Is an Index Fund, Exactly?

An index is a list. The S&P 500 is a list of about 500 of the largest companies listed on US stock exchanges, and it covers roughly 80% of all US equities by market value, according to Investopedia. Other well-known indexes include the Nasdaq Composite, which holds about 3,000 stocks listed on the Nasdaq exchange, and the Dow Jones Industrial Average, which holds just 30 large companies chosen by the editors of the Wall Street Journal. An index fund buys the stocks on one of these lists, in the same proportions as the list itself. If a company is 7% of the index, it is roughly 7% of the fund. When the index changes, the fund changes. The rest of the time, the fund does almost nothing — which is the point.

The idea is not new. The first index fund for ordinary investors, the Vanguard 500 Index Fund, was launched in 1976 by Vanguard's founder John Bogle. For years it was treated as a curiosity. Then the money started moving: passive index funds held just 21% of the US equity fund market in 2021, and by 2023 they accounted for about half of all US fund assets, according to Investopedia. The shift happened because the funds kept doing something simple and hard to argue with — matching the market at a very low price.

It is a strategy, not a single product. You can buy one that tracks US stocks, international stocks, bonds, or a whole market. The best-known are S&P 500 funds, but the same idea works for almost any index. What they share is the refusal to pick winners. The fund owns the market, or a slice of it, and lets the market do the work.

What Is an Index Fund and How Does It Work?

When you buy a share of one, your money is spread across every company in the index. One purchase can put you in hundreds or even thousands of companies at once. That spread is called diversification, and it is the main reason a single bad company cannot wreck your savings the way a single bad stock pick can.

The fund's managers — and "managers" is a generous word here — have one job: keep the fund matched to the index. They buy and sell only when the index itself changes, or to keep the weightings in line. That is why index funds trade far less often than actively managed funds, and why they cost less to run.

How closely do they track? Very closely. As of August 2024, Fidelity's Nasdaq Composite Index Fund had a 10-year average annual return of 15.54%, against 15.57% for the Nasdaq Composite itself — a gap of 0.03%, according to Investopedia. The tiny difference is the fund's costs and the mechanics of tracking. A fund that lags its index by much more than its expense ratio is a warning sign; a fund that matches it is doing its job.

One thing it will never do is beat the market. It is designed to match it, minus a small fee. For most long-term investors, that turns out to be enough — which brings us to the evidence.

Index Fund vs ETF vs Mutual Fund: What's the Difference?

This is where beginners get confused, because "index fund" describes a strategy, while "ETF" and "mutual fund" describe the wrapper the strategy comes in. The same index-tracking strategy can be sold as either.

An index mutual fund is bought directly from the fund company. You place your order and it is priced once a day, after the market closes, at the fund's net asset value. Mutual funds make automatic investing easy: you can set up a fixed monthly contribution and reinvest dividends without thinking about it. Some have minimum investments — Vanguard's Admiral shares, for example, require $3,000, while Fidelity and Schwab index funds have no minimum at all, according to Investopedia's fund table.

An index ETF — exchange-traded fund — is bought and sold on a stock exchange during the day, like a share. You can buy a single share, use limit orders, and see the price move in real time. ETFs are usually slightly more tax-efficient than mutual funds, because of the way they create and redeem shares, and they often have no minimum beyond the price of one share.

An actively managed mutual fund is the opposite of both. A manager and a team of analysts pick stocks they think will win, trade frequently, and charge for the effort. That is the fund the SPIVA numbers measure — and the one that usually loses to the index.

Which wrapper should you pick? For most beginners, it hardly matters. The index you track and the fee you pay matter far more than whether the fund is an ETF or a mutual fund. If you want automatic monthly investing, a mutual fund is simpler. If you want to buy a single share with no minimum, an ETF is easier. If you are still deciding between the two main things a fund can hold, our guide to the difference between stocks and bonds explains the building blocks first.

What Does an Index Fund Cost?

Cost is where they win their clearest victory. The fee is called the expense ratio: the percentage of your money the fund keeps each year to cover its costs. Because an index fund has no research team picking stocks, it can charge far less than an actively managed fund. According to Investopedia, index funds often cost as little as 0.04% a year, while actively managed funds typically charge 0.44% — and sometimes more than 1.00%.

The cheapest well-known S&P 500 funds charge even less. NerdWallet's list, using Morningstar data current as of September 3, 2026, puts the Fidelity 500 Index Fund at 0.015%, the Schwab S&P 500 Index Fund at 0.020%, and the Vanguard 500 Index Fund Admiral Shares at 0.040%. Fidelity even offers ZERO funds that charge 0.000%. Bond index funds are similarly cheap: the Fidelity US Bond Index Fund costs 0.025% and Vanguard's Total Bond Market Index Fund costs 0.040%.

Percentages hide the real cost, so put it in dollars. On a $10,000 investment, a 0.04% expense ratio costs $4 a year. A 1.00% fee on the same $10,000 costs $100 a year — 25 times as much — for a fund that, on the evidence, is more likely to trail the market than beat it. The gap gets worse over time, because fees compound against you just as returns compound for you. Our guide to compound interest shows how a 1% annual fee quietly eats into long-term growth.

Two funds can track the same index and charge very different fees, so the expense ratio is the first number to check before you buy — ahead of past performance, and ahead of the fund's brand name.

The Evidence: Most Stock Pickers Lose to the Index

The claim that they beat most active funds is not marketing. It comes from S&P's SPIVA scorecards, which compare actively managed funds with their benchmarks. According to data last published in mid-2024, 79% of actively managed funds had underperformed the S&P 500 over the previous five years. Stretch the window to 15 years and the figure rises to 88% — about nine in ten active funds failed to match the benchmark, as reported by Investopedia.

Why do professionals lose so often? Fees are part of it — a fund charging 1% a year starts every year 1% behind. The rest is the difficulty of the job: to beat the market you have to be right about which stocks will win, and right again about when to sell them, year after year, while paying trading costs. A few managers do it for a while. Almost none do it for 15 years running.

The funds themselves have delivered solid long-term returns — not because they are clever, but because the market itself has risen over time. Investopedia's fund table shows 10-year average annual returns of 12.94% for the Vanguard 500 Index Fund, 13.08% for the Fidelity 500 Index Fund, 13.08% for the Schwab S&P 500 Index Fund, and 12.51% for the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund. Those are past returns over one particular decade, not a promise. The next decade could be lower, and there will be years when the numbers are negative. The point is not the size of the returns — it is that the cheap fund keeping pace with the market beat nearly nine in ten of the expensive funds trying to outsmart it.

How to Start Investing in Index Funds

1. Sort the foundations first. Start with money you will not need for years. Before you invest, build a starter emergency fund and deal with expensive debt. The 50/30/20 budget rule gives you a simple way to split your take-home pay — 50% for needs, 30% for wants, 20% for savings and debt repayment — and our US personal finance guide walks through the full order: budget, emergency fund, debt, then investing.

2. Open an account. In most countries you invest through a brokerage account — an online platform where you deposit money and place orders. In the US that might be a brokerage account or an IRA; in the UK an ISA; in Canada an RRSP or TFSA; in Australia, superannuation or a standard brokerage account. Pick a reputable, regulated broker and verify your identity.

3. Choose your index. Most beginners start with a broad one: an S&P 500 fund or a total stock market fund for US stocks, plus an international fund and a bond fund if you want a complete portfolio. Narrow funds that track one sector or one country are a later step, not a first one.

4. Check the expense ratio and the minimum. Two funds tracking the same index can charge very different fees. Look for the lowest expense ratio among large, well-established funds, and check the minimum — some funds need $3,000 to start, others need nothing at all.

5. Buy, then automate. Set up a fixed monthly contribution so you invest on a schedule instead of trying to time the market. Regular investing through ups and downs is called dollar-cost averaging, and it removes the hardest decision — when to buy — from the process entirely.

6. Review twice a year, and leave it alone the rest of the time. Check that the fund is still tracking its index and that the fee has not crept up. Do not sell in a panic when markets fall; the investors who come out ahead are usually the ones who kept investing through downturns instead of selling at the bottom.

The Risks: Index Funds Can Fall Too

Index funds are lower-risk than picking individual stocks, but they are not low-risk. When the market falls, the fund falls with it — there is no manager to move your money into cash or into safer stocks. In severe downturns, stock markets have fallen 40% or more before recovering, and a fund tracking them falls by the same amount. Anyone who needs the money within a few years should keep it in savings, not in the market.

There is also concentration risk. Most big index funds are weighted by company size, so the largest companies have the biggest influence on returns. If a handful of giant companies stumble, the whole fund feels it. That is the trade-off for owning the market: you own its giants too.

And remember what the fund cannot do: it cannot beat the market, it cannot protect you in a crash, and its past returns say nothing about its future ones. The 10-year figures above describe one decade, not the next one. It is a sensible default for long-term money — not a guarantee, and not a substitute for an emergency fund or for paying down expensive debt first.

What to Do Next

Why does any of this matter? Because the default choice for most people's long-term money should be the cheapest one that captures the market's return — and the evidence says that choice beat nearly nine in ten professionals trying to do better. The work is not picking the perfect fund. It is setting up the boring parts: a budget that leaves 20% for savings, an emergency fund, and an automatic monthly contribution into a low-cost one. Start with one broad fund, check its expense ratio, automate the contribution, and review it twice a year. That is the whole strategy — and the reason it works is that there is so little of it to get wrong.

This article is general educational information, not investment advice. Consider speaking with a licensed financial professional before investing.