Italy fines Meta €805 million. That is the decision from Rome, where Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, announced on Saturday 14 November 2026 that it had fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited €805 million — about $887 million — after finding that the Facebook app on Android phones reached into users' photo galleries without their specific consent. About 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. The ruling turns on a single feature, running since 2023, that suggests photos and videos from a phone's gallery as ideas for a Facebook post. Meta says it will appeal and calls the penalty "disproportionate". What follows is what the feature did, why the regulator says the consent behind it was not good enough, what Meta must change within 60 days, and what it means for anyone who uses Facebook on Android.
Italy fines Meta €805 million: what the Facebook feature actually did
The feature at the centre of the case is called "Get suggestions from your gallery when browsing Facebook" — in Italian, "Ottieni suggerimenti dalla galleria quando navighi su Facebook". When someone starts a post, Facebook offers up photos and videos from the phone's gallery as suggestions for what to share. It sounds helpful, and for many people it is the point of the feature: a nudge to post a picture they might otherwise forget.
The Garante's objection is not to the idea of suggestions. It is to how Facebook got hold of the pictures. According to the authority, the Facebook app for Android reached into users' galleries through a single, app-wide authorisation — one broad permission that covered the whole app and several functions with different purposes. The notice users saw beforehand did not make clear that the company would also use their pictures to generate post suggestions. The feature was also switched on by default, so people did not have to choose to turn it on; it was already running.
The authority says the practice is still going on for people who have not updated the app and for those who already gave their consent under the old wording. Its decision covers photos, videos and the metadata attached to them — the information that travels with each picture, such as when and where it was taken.
Why the consent failed: one blanket permission is not enough
The Garante based its decision on Article 122 of the Italian Privacy Code, the provision that puts the European Union's ePrivacy Directive into Italian law. That rule treats a smartphone as part of a person's private life. Any access to what the phone stores therefore needs free and informed consent, whether or not the data is sent anywhere and whether or not any harm results.
That is a stricter test than most people expect. Consent, in the regulator's reading, has to be specific: a clear yes to one particular use of personal material. A general approval given to an app at the outset does not amount to a clear answer about one particular use of someone's pictures. The Hacker News, reporting the decision, put the authority's reasoning plainly: the app asked for gallery access through a single permission covering the whole app, and the wording never made clear that the user was also authorising gallery suggestions.
The investigation began in July 2025, after a report from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti di Bolzano, a consumer protection centre in the South Tyrol capital. The Garante then ran its own technical analysis of how the app behaved. In setting the size of the fine, it weighed the scale of the practice — about 20 million Android users in Italy — the fact that it was still ongoing, a previous regulatory action against the company in 2019, and what it described as limited cooperation during the investigation.
Italy fines Meta €805 million: who was affected and what Meta must do now
The fine, €805 million, equals about 0.47 percent of Meta's worldwide turnover, according to the Garante. The BBC reported it as about £670 million and called it one of the largest fines an Italian authority has ever imposed on a technology company. Reuters put the dollar figure at about $887 million.
Alongside the money, the Garante ordered Meta to change how the feature works for users in Italy. Within 60 days, the company must switch the gallery-suggestions feature off by default and ask users for separate, specific consent before it can run again. Meta must also report back on the measures it has adopted within 90 days. Anyone who has not given that separate consent will not have the feature running on their phone.
Meta rejected the regulator's conclusions. A spokesperson said the company would appeal and called the penalty "disproportionate". Meta's position is that the feature only works once a user grants permission on the device — a point the Garante evidently did not accept as sufficient, because the permission in question covered the app as a whole rather than the gallery feature in particular. The fine is small against the scale of the company — Meta priced a $37.5 billion stock offering in late October — but the order to rebuild the consent flow is the part that will cost engineering time and could change how the feature works well beyond Italy if Meta applies the same design everywhere.
Why Italy fined Meta — and not Ireland
Meta argued that Ireland should have handled the case. Its European headquarters is in Dublin, and under the EU's one-stop-shop system one lead regulator usually takes charge of a company operating across the bloc. The Garante disagreed. It said the one-stop-shop system does not apply to the ePrivacy rules at issue here, because the phone-privacy provision it enforced is national law implementing an EU directive, not the GDPR.
That matters beyond this one fine. If other national regulators take the same view, Meta could face separate ePrivacy cases in other member states over the same feature, each with its own penalty. It is not the first time Meta's handling of personal data has drawn a large fine: the company faced a privacy fine in New Mexico in October 2026, and it paused a sharing feature the same month after a privacy flaw. The Italian decision adds a European chapter to that record, and one with a legal theory other regulators can copy.
What the ruling leaves open: AI training and the cloud feature
One question the decision does not answer is whether the photos and videos Facebook accessed were used to train artificial intelligence models. The investigation did not cover that, and the Garante said so plainly. Meta has denied using content accessed this way to train AI. For users, that leaves an awkward gap: the ruling establishes that the access happened without proper consent, but not what happened to the material afterwards.
The Garante also kept a second door open. It reserved the right to assess separately a newer feature, introduced in 2026, that allows content from users' galleries to be processed in the cloud. That feature was not part of this fine, and a separate decision on it could follow. The 60-day order covers the suggestions feature that has run since 2023; the cloud feature is a different question, and it may be the more consequential one, because processing in the cloud means the pictures leave the phone.
What happens next for Facebook users
Meta says it will appeal, and that process will take months. The 60-day clock, however, is already running. Users in Italy should expect a new, separate prompt asking whether Facebook may look through their gallery for post suggestions, with the feature switched off until they say yes.
For users outside Italy, this decision changes nothing directly: the order covers Italy. But the principle travels. The Garante has now said, in a decision worth €805 million, that a phone's photo gallery is private space and that a vague permission screen is not consent. Anyone who uses Facebook on Android can check the same thing on their own phone today — open the app's permissions in the phone's settings and look at what Facebook is allowed to read — and decide whether each permission earns its place. That, rather than the size of the fine, is the part of this ruling most likely to be felt beyond Italy.
Sources: Reuters; BBC; The Hacker News; PYMNTS; MakeTechEasier; Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, press release "Facebook: il Garante Privacy sanziona Meta per 805 milioni di euro", 14 November 2026 (doc-web 10321080).